V Squat Vs Hack Squat: Which Machine Should You Use?

In the v squat vs hack squat debate, pick the hack squat for a simple, locked path that hammers the front of the thigh (quadriceps).

Pick the V squat machine for a start that can be lighter and a setup you can tilt toward quads or glutes. Most lifters do fine with either, and plenty use both.

Oddly, the plates you load on each say almost nothing about which is harder.

Here, V squat means the plate loaded machine with shoulder pads on a swinging arm, not a wide stance squat.

Key Takeaways

  • The hack squat runs on a straight rail with your back on a pad, so your quads do most of the work.
  • The V squat machine swings in an arc, and you can face out or face in.
  • Depth and foot position likely matter more than the machine.
  • Never compare plates between machines. Starting weight, rail angle and lever arm all change the number.
  • Cranky knees or a sore lower back usually call for a setup change, not a ban.

V Squat And Hack Squat Side By Side

Both machines train the same main muscles, so this V squat vs hack squat table shows where they differ: path, stance, starting weight and depth.

FactorV Squat MachineHack Squat Machine
PathArc on a pivoting lever armStraight rail at a fixed angle
How you standFacing out or facing inBack on the pad
TorsoChanges with direction and stanceFixed flat against the pad
Hips and kneesHips can travel backKnees travel well forward
Starting weight54 lb on one model125 lb, same brand
Main musclesQuads, glutes, inner thighQuads, glutes, inner thigh
Depth limitWhere your lower back stays flatWhere the sled stops or heels lift
Best forFlexible setup, sometimes a lighter startSimple, locked path for quads

What Is A V Squat Machine?

A V squat machine is plate loaded. You stand on an angled foot plate under shoulder pads that ride on a swinging lever arm. You can face out, with your back on the pad, or face in, which people call a reverse V squat.

The name also gets used for a wide stance dumbbell squat, a different exercise.

What Is A Hack Squat Machine?

A hack squat machine is a plate loaded sled on straight rails at a fixed angle, often 45 degrees. Your back and shoulders rest on pads, feet on a large foot plate.

Our guide on how the hack squat compares with a regular squat covers that matchup.

How To Tell Which Machine Your Gym Has

Gyms rarely label these machines, and three of them look alike from across the room.

  • Straight rails with a sled that slides along them: hack squat.
  • Shoulder pads on an arm that pivots low, behind where you stand: V squat.
  • Shoulder pads on an arm that hangs from a pivot up high: pendulum squat, a different arc machine.

This guide covers the first two.

Of all the rows in that table, the path explains the most, so start there.

1. The Path: Straight Rail Vs Arc

Both machines put pads on your shoulders, so why does one feel like a pure thigh burner and the other more like a real squat? The answer is the line the weight travels.

The Hack Squat Moves In A Straight Line

The sled runs on bearings along a fixed rail. Your back stays flat on the pad, so your knees have to travel forward as you go down.

That knee led, stable path is why coaches rate it so highly for quads.

The V Squat Swings In An Arc

The shoulder pads sit on an arm that swings around a pivot, so your shoulders travel in a curve. Hammer Strength has built both machines.

Its V squat page describes the hack squat as a strict, linear path that emphasizes the quads, and the V squat as a more hip dominant pattern.

Facing out, the arc tends to send your hips back: more bend at the hip, less at the knee. Facing in lets you choose your torso angle. Because the arm is a lever, the weight can also feel different through the rep.

What The Path Does To Your Torso, Knees And Depth

  • Torso: fixed against the pad on the hack squat. On the V squat it depends on direction and stance.
  • Knees: forward travel is built into the hack squat. On the V squat your hips can travel back, which takes some work off the knees (section 4).
  • Depth: some hack squat sleds hit their bottom stop before full depth, especially for shorter lifters. On the V squat the limit is usually where your lower back starts to round.
Side view illustration of a man on a hack squat machine with a straight arrow along the rails, next to a man on a V squat machine with a curved arrow around the pivot at the rear base

A straight rail means a locked torso and knees forward. An arc means more say over where your hips go.

2. Muscles Worked: Quads Lead On Both, Setup Decides The Rest

As far as we could find, no study has tested the V squat machine or compared it with the hack squat. So we lean on how each machine moves, what coaches see and squat research.

What Both Machines Train

The quads do most of the work on both. The glutes, inner thigh (adductors) and hamstrings help, and your trunk holds you steady.

No squat pattern machine isolates one muscle.

How Your Feet Shift The Work

On the hack squat, high feet turn it into more of a regular squat: more glute work, and a lower back that can round at the bottom. Low, close feet keep the work on the quads, but go too low and your heels lift.

A very wide stance can shift work toward the inner thigh. No single width is correct, so keep the one your quads and joints like best.

Why Depth Matters More Than The Machine

A study of 17 men compared full and half squats, twice a week for 10 weeks. Quad growth was almost the same: about 4.9 percent with full squats and 4.6 with half.

The glutes grew about 6.7 percent with full squats against 2.2 with half, and the inner thigh 6.2 against 2.7. The hamstrings did not grow at either depth. So plan a leg curl or a deadlift variation for them.

Neither machine was tested, but the reasoning carries over: deeper, controlled reps should give your glutes and inner thigh more work. For quads alone, half depth did about as well in this study.

The machine sets the path, but your feet and depth shape which muscles do the most work. Neither is the glute machine by default.

3. Why You Lift More On One Machine Than The Other

You stack plates on the V squat with room to spare, then two plates a side on the hack squat crush you. Or the reverse.

You did not get weaker. The machines count weight differently.

Each Machine Starts At A Different Weight

  • The Hammer Strength V squat from section 1 lists a starting resistance of 54 pounds before plates.
  • The same brand lists 125 pounds for its hack squat.

Many brands publish no figure, so check your machine’s label.

Angles And Levers Change What You Actually Lift

On a 45 degree rail, only about 71 percent of the moving weight (plates plus sled) pushes down the rail. So 90 pounds of plates on a 100 pound sled is 190 pounds, or about 134 along the rail. The same idea applies to how much a leg press sled weighs.

Rails are not all set at 45 degrees either, so that share changes from one hack squat to the next.

On a V squat the plates sit on a lever arm, so how far they sit from the pivot changes the load again. We found no published number for that.

Why A Machine Number Beats Your Barbell Number

A study of 10 men found they lifted significantly more on the hack squat than on the barbell back squat.

Their trunk muscles still worked harder under the barbell, and the researchers credited the machine’s trunk support for the bigger number.

Track each machine against itself: write down the machine, your foot position and the weight.

4. Knees And Lower Back: Which Is Kinder?

Knees grumbling after hack squats, or lower back tight after the V squat? Each path leans on a different joint.

Knees

A study doing barbell squats found that keeping the knees behind the toes cut knee load by about a fifth. Hip load rose more than tenfold, which the researchers warned likely shifts stress to the hips and lower back.

Their takeaway was that loading the joints sensibly may mean letting the knees travel slightly past the toes.

Neither machine was tested, but the trade should carry over: the hack squat is knee led, and a hips back V squat is more hip led.

Heavy, low rep hack squats can leave your knees and the tendon above the kneecap sore, so sets of 10 to 20 sit better. Feet a little higher on the plate may ease knee pressure there too.

Lower Back

On either machine, your lower back takes the stress once your pelvis rolls under at the bottom, so stop just short of that.

A hips back setup also asks more of your lower back, which is the trade the 2003 study pointed to.

Sharp or lingering pain means stop and see a physical therapist.

Easier on touchy knees: a hips back V squat, or a hack squat with feet a little higher. Skip the hips back setup if your lower back is the sore spot.

5. Facing In Or Facing Out On The V Squat

Coaches disagree on this one. The more common view is that facing out is the hip led setup, which matches the maker’s description in section 1, and that facing in is the quad setup. Others use facing in for glutes.

Both camps can be right, because what moves the work is how far your hips travel back and your knees travel forward.

Not every V squat is built for facing in. Before you load it, check that you can still reach the safety handles from that side.

Side view illustration of the two ways to use a V squat machine: facing out with the hips pushed back, and facing in with an upright torso and knees forward

Set Up For Quads

  • Keep your torso as vertical as you can.
  • Let your knees travel forward.
  • Get as much knee bend as you can control.

Facing in often makes this easier, because you pick your own torso angle.

Set Up For Glutes

  • Start each rep by sending your hips back.
  • Keep your shins fairly vertical, knees over your heel to midfoot.
  • Let your torso tip forward as your hips go back.
  • Go as deep as you can with a flat lower back. Depth is what gave the glutes more growth in section 2.

Facing out usually makes this easier, because the arc already sends your hips back.

Coaches differ on stance: hip width with toes forward, or slightly wider than shoulder width with toes out. Try both and keep the one where you feel your glutes.

Either way, stop before your pelvis rolls under. You can face in on a hack squat machine too, which our reverse hack squat guide covers.

Pick your goal first, then face whichever way lets you hit those positions on your machine.

6. How To Do A V Squat And A Hack Squat With Good Form

A minute on foot position and depth before your first set decides whether either machine works your legs or your lower back.

How To Do A V Squat

  • Load the plates and step on facing out: shoulders under the pads, feet about shoulder width, toes slightly out.
  • Stand up and release the safety handles.
  • Breathe in and bend your knees and hips together, back flat on the pad, knees tracking over your toes.
  • Go as low as you can with your heels down and your lower back flat, usually around thighs parallel to the foot plate.
  • Drive through your whole foot to stand, without slamming into lockout.
  • Lock the safety handles back in before you step off.

Facing in, set your chest toward the machine and follow the same steps without the back pad cue (section 5 has the rest). Set the safety stops if your machine has them.

How To Do A Hack Squat

  • Set your back flat on the pad, shoulders under the pads, feet about shoulder width in the middle of the plate.
  • Press up slightly and unlock the safety handles.
  • Lower for about 2 seconds, knees traveling forward over your toes.
  • Go as deep as you can with your heels down and your back on the pad, until your thighs are parallel to the foot plate or lower.
  • Push through your whole foot to stand.
  • Lock the safety handles again at the top before you step off.

If the sled bottoms out before you reach depth, look for a range of motion setting first.

If there is none, stand on a firm, non slip mat on the foot plate, or put a yoga block between each shoulder and its pad. Test it with an empty sled before you add plates.

Your First Session On Either Machine

Do 2 sets of 10 with no plates to learn the path and find your depth. Then add weight in small jumps until the last 2 or 3 reps feel hard.

Mistakes To Avoid On Both

  • Heels lifting. Move your feet a little higher, or wear lifting shoes.
  • Feet too high on the hack squat. Your back rounds and your hips peel off the pad.
  • Knees caving in.
  • Pelvis rolling under. Stop just before it.
  • Dropping fast. Take about 2 seconds down.
  • Copying your load from the other machine. Start light on the new one.
Illustration of a V squat and a hack squat with four numbered setup checkpoints on each machine and a matching checklist underneath

The hack squat punishes bad foot placement, and the V squat punishes a drifting lower back. Heels down and a flat back fix most of both.

7. Which One Should You Pick?

For most goals, V squat vs hack squat is a tie, because setup likely matters more than the machine. A few cases do have a winner.

Pick By Goal

Your GoalPickWhy
Bigger quads, simplest setupHack squatLocked path, knees forward
Glute focusV squat, hips backEasier to send hips back
Tall or long thighsTry the V squat facing inYou set your torso angle
Stiff anklesEither, with feet a little higherNeeds less ankle bend
Knee historyHips back V squat, or hack squat with feet higherSee section 4
Cranky lower backEither, upright and knee led, stopping before your pelvis tucksSee section 4
Shorter lifterV squat, or hack squat with matsSome sleds bottom out early
New to the gymV squatLighter start on some models

If Your Gym Only Has One

  • Only a hack squat: for glutes, set your feet a little higher and go deep with a flat back, or try it reversed (section 5).
  • Only a V squat: stay upright and push your knees forward for quads, which facing in often makes easier. Use the hips back setup for glutes.
  • Home gym: both are big. The V squat model in section 3 weighs 530 pounds and covers roughly 8 by 4 feet, and the same brand’s hack squat weighs 504 pounds and covers roughly 7 by 5 feet. Most home lifters do better with hack squat alternatives.

Using only one? Take the hack squat for quads, or the V squat for glutes or a lighter start, then work on depth and progression.

8. How To Use Both In One Week

You do not have to choose, because the two machines fit on two different leg days.

Treat these numbers as a starting point.

  • Two leg days: hack squat on day 1 for quads, 3 sets of 10 to 15, feet shoulder width. V squat on day 2 with your section 5 setup, 3 sets of 12 to 20.
  • One session: do the one you want to push hardest first, then 2 sets on the other.
  • On a day with heavy Romanian deadlifts: keep your machine squat upright and knee led, since a hips back setup adds lower back work.
  • Most sets: stop 1 to 2 reps short of failure. Add reps first, then weight.

Best for lifters with both machines and two leg days. Skip the second machine if your weekly leg sets are already high and recovery is struggling.

Bottom Line

So which one gets your next leg day?

The hack squat’s straight rail pins your back and drives your knees forward, which makes it a simple quad builder.

The V squat swings in an arc, can start lighter and can be set up for quads or glutes.

Pick by goal and comfort, and ignore the number on the plates. If your gym has both, use both across the week.

Next session, set your feet, find the depth where your heels stay down and your back stays flat, and write down the weight for that machine only.

FAQs

Is V Squat Better Than Hack Squat?

Neither is better overall. The hack squat is the simpler pick for quads, while the V squat can start lighter and can be set up for quads or glutes. Depth and foot position likely matter more than which machine you use.

Why Can I Lift More On V Squat Than Hack Squat?

Each machine starts at a different weight, a sloped rail only puts part of the load on you, and a lever arm changes it again. The plate numbers measure different things, so track each machine on its own and never compare them.

What Is A Reverse V Squat?

It is the V squat machine used facing in, with your chest toward the machine and the pads on your shoulders. Stay upright with your knees traveling forward for quads, or send your hips back for glutes. Not every V squat is built for it, so check your machine first.

Does The V Squat Work Glutes?

Yes, along with your quads and inner thigh. Sending your hips back and squatting deeper with a flat back gives your glutes more work. The hack squat trains them too, so neither machine is the glute machine by default.

Is V Squat Or Hack Squat Better For Bad Knees?

Neither is safe or unsafe by default. Sending your hips back can take some load off the knees but adds work for your hips and lower back, and feet a little higher on the hack squat can ease knee pressure. Sharp or lingering pain means see a physical therapist.

Leave a Comment

0 Shares
Share
Pin
Tweet
Reddit